Mayer gets his muse when he meets actress Jennifer Love Hewitt. The two begin an intense – but brief – relationship. "It was a strange little detour that I took for a minute," he tells Entertainment Weekly, admitting he had been "madly in love." "It sucks. Because the idea of it was fantastic. It just didn`t work." As for the rumor that "Your Body is a Wonderland" is an ode to Hewitt? Not so, she insists to PEOPLE. "John would have written, `Your body is a disaster.`"