he and hilary was the perfect couple ever. seriously, i cant understand why they broke up. i know he has a family now, but i cant see nicole the perfect woman for him! JILARY forever <333

I feel sorry for Joel for being with that whiny douche bag. I never expected him to be with either one of those girls. I expected him to be with a rebellious girl. (more of a girl who isnt famous) But oh well, he doesnt really have high expectations in a girl if he chose nicole richie. I mean does she even eat? Disgusting.

Joel Wat ever ur Name Is U WAS NOT BORN 2 FELL IN LOVE WITH HILARY OK

Joel and Nicole are the most amazing couple ever and their so real to their not all like oh we are the best couple ever. Because, they have had a few bumps along the road obviously but their still amazing in my book. And Harlow is sooo cute. Cant wait to see the baby on its way!

I didn`t mind Joel and Hilary, but I really despise him and Nicole. Yea cause I`m jealous lol who isn`t? I`m happy for him though and Nicole probably doesn`t realize how lucky she actually is, being with him and having his child and another one on the way. <3 Joel xD

well, even I don`t like Nicole very much, I think that they are great couple, they have really happy family, beautiful daughter Harlow and now they are waiting for another baby. I think it`s amasing and you guys must be happy for him ) It`s not our business to work out is Nicole right for him or not !!! If he`s happy-we`re happy too<333

I think Joel and Hilary were a perfect couple. I know him and nicole have a child Harlow Who is adorable! but i believe him an hilary should be together . She was more of a rocker chick. plus good charlotte rules (:

hottie.

i love u so much i have even made you a nickname and it is joelie i think that you are good wid nicole but i dislike her. harlow is so cute hehehe LOVE ALIX frendo lives in victoria

Ohmg, Joel is so hot! I love his band, Good Charlotte. Joel and Nicole are really cool couple and Harlow has the same birth-date as me! wow :D

Okay, Benji date Sophie Monk not Joel. Im really happy for him, but I think it would have been cool if he was with more of a rocker chick, same with Benji! BTW, Harlow is so cute!!!

I think Joel, Nicole and their baby make an awesome family. I like both of them more now that they are parents.

dude joel madden is so hottttttt but the only thing in his life i dont like is nicole but harlow is suppper cute he should have stayed with hilary duff they were a perfect couple

I thought that joel and hillary were ok together but personally i don`t like the idea of him with nicole. Harlow is adorable though and they do look happy. I just don`t like that he used to be a punk/rocker but now he is wearin really gay hats (no offense joel) and has a beard sumtimes that makes him look older and just different. I just want the old joel madden back and don`t think the relationship will last long with him and nicole. Even though i don`t like nicole joel madden is my hero and idol so i will say this if he`s happy i`m happy and wish the best of luck to him. O and good charlotte kix ass!!!

joel madden is so hottttttttt

personally i think joel and nicole are good together and will last. yeh i agree, what the media says isnt always true so why have a pointless arguement or disrespect joel for what the media is telling you? I think your baby is adorable=)

I think Joel and Nicole are adorable together. ANd their daughter is the cutest!!!

I think that Joel should of stayed with Hilary Duff. I think their breakup was just a break. I think they were the cutiest couple. She should of had his baby instead of Nicole. I think deep down Joel still loved Hilary and Nicole was a rebound girl. I can`t say anything bad about Nicole I think she is pretty and nice. Their baby is cute as a button but the relationship will never last. It should of been Hilary!!!!

No one should be saying anything about his relationships anyway. What you see in the media is so much different to how they are behind closed doors so dont go telling people to shut up because of it.

I dont know too much about this whole joel and baby thing or anything about Hilary. But anyone who disaproves him and Nicole are stupid. From what I see, he supports her in every way he can. He loves her to death. and I think someone who gets mad about it,they`re jealous.