2
Nina Dobrev and Ian Somerhalder separated in Apr 2013 after dating for 1 year...
[view relationship]
4
Ashley Greene and Gerard Butler were rumored to be separated in 2011 after dating for 5 months...
[view relationship]
5
Jennifer Aniston and Gerard Butler were rumored to be separated in Jul 2009 after dating for 1 month...
[view relationship]