(6 May 2007 - present) (separated) (2 children)
Brewster lived in Los Angeles with her then husband, producer Andrew Form, whom she met on the set of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre: The Beginning, in which Brewster acted. They announced their engagement on November 4, 2006. They married in a private ceremony in the Bahamas on May 6, 2007.They have two sons. The marriage ended in early 2020.