In 2016, then 27-year-old Florida-based real estate agent, Jay Starrett, competed on Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X. While no one took him seriously at first, he quickly became a huge threat after he orchestrated the blindside of ally Michaela Bradshaw and won two individual immunity challenges. The Survivor star then began dating Big Brother: Over the Top winner Morgan Willett in the summer of 2018, but she “ghosted” him. Therefore, he appeared on MTV’s Ex on the Beach as one of the multiple exes who came for the BBOT star in hopes of rekindling their romance. They did and continued their relationship in the real world for a few months until she left to compete on The Challenge. Starrett accused his then-girlfriend of cheating on him with Challenge veteran, Johnny “Bananas” Devenanzio. She vehemently denies this and insists she began a romantic relationship with the MTV star after Starrett broke up with her. The Survivor star is competing in The Challenge Season 35, Total Madness, against Devenanzio, who is currently dating the BBOT champ.