Back in New York in 1992, one of Roberta’s Elle magazine covers caught the eye of Toby Myers, then a member of John Mellencamp’s band. Mellencamp was dating Elaine Irwin, another of the Ford Agency models, and Roberta’s one-time roommate. Myers talked Irwin into making an introduction. Roberta was sick with the flu when Myers first came to her apartment. He brought her soup and took care of her. “He stayed and never left,” she said. They were married in 1995 at Farm Aid, on stage in front of 50,000 people. After 17 years in Mellencamp’s band, Myers quit when their son Cash was born in 1999, and Roberta quit modeling about the same time. Wanting a slower pace of life, they moved to Toby's home state of Indiana. Cash is now a senior at Brown County High School, planning on attending Indiana University next term. Roberta and Toby are still married, and she is now gallery manager at the Brown County Art Guild in Brown County, Indiana.